How to Choose the Right Toilet for Your Home: A Comprehensive Guide

Nov 10, 2023 | Resources

Service by Scott is your trusted partner for all your plumbing and maintenance needs. As a family-owned and operated full-service plumbing company in Woodville, Texas, we bring over 30 years of experience to our community and neighboring areas. We are fully licensed, ensuring the highest standards of professionalism and reliability.

At Service by Scott, no job is too small or too large for us. We specialize in a wide range of services, including slab leak detection and repair, plumbing repair, installation, inspection, and water heater maintenance. In addition, we cater to the needs of both small businesses and industrial-scale operations, offering commercial plumbing installations and repairs. With our commitment to excellence, we provide 24/7 emergency service, ensuring that you can rely on us when plumbing issues arise, day or night.

This guide will offer you valuable insights into choosing the perfect toilet for your home. Just as we’ve been a reliable choice for the plumbing needs of our community, we’re here to assist you in making an informed decision about a crucial household fixture. From understanding toilet types to evaluating water efficiency and budget considerations, we’ve got you covered. Let’s begin this journey to ensure you select the right toilet for your home, with Service by Scott at your side.

choose the right toilet

Understanding Toilet Types

When choosing the perfect toilet for your home, understanding the different types available is the first crucial step. Each type of toilet comes with its own set of characteristics, advantages, and considerations. Let’s explore these toilet types to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your specific needs and preferences.

Two-Piece Toilets

  • Affordability: Two-piece toilets are often the budget-friendly choice. They consist of a separate tank and bowl, which can be more cost-effective to manufacture and replace if necessary.
  • Maintenance: These toilets are easy to maintain since you can access the tank and bowl separately. Repairs and replacements for individual parts are generally straightforward, making them a practical option for many households.

One-Piece Toilets

  • Sleek Design: One-piece toilets feature a seamless and sleek design with no crevices between the tank and bowl. This design not only looks modern but also makes cleaning easier, as there are fewer areas for dirt and grime to accumulate.
  • Ease of Cleaning: The absence of seams and joints simplifies the cleaning process. With fewer areas for bacteria to hide, one-piece toilets are an excellent choice for those who prioritize cleanliness and hygiene.

Wall-Mounted Toilets

  • Space-Saving: Wall-mounted toilets are ideal for bathrooms with limited space. Since the tank is concealed within the wall, it saves valuable floor space, creating a more open and spacious feel.
  • Modern Aesthetics: These toilets offer a contemporary and minimalistic appearance. The flush plate and bowl typically feature a sleek design, adding a touch of modern sophistication to your bathroom.

Choosing the right toilet type largely depends on your budget, maintenance preferences, and the aesthetics you desire for your bathroom. Keep these factors in mind as you decide which type of toilet best suits your needs.

Key Features to Consider

When selecting the perfect toilet for your home, understanding the key features is paramount. These features have a direct impact on the toilet’s efficiency, comfort, and overall performance. In this section, we will explore these key features to help you make an informed choice that aligns with your specific needs and preferences.

Water-saving Options

  • Dual Flush Technology: Many modern toilets are equipped with a dual flush system, providing the flexibility of a full flush for solid waste and a reduced flush for liquid waste. This option allows you to use water efficiently, reducing water consumption and bills.
  • Low-Flow Innovation: Low-flow toilets are designed to use significantly less water per flush while maintaining effective waste removal. These toilets are eco-friendly and can help you contribute to water conservation efforts.

Bowl Shapes

  • Elongated Bowls: Elongated toilet bowls offer extra sitting space and are known for their comfort. They provide a more ergonomic design, making them a popular choice for those seeking a spacious and comfortable experience.
  • Round Bowls: Round bowls are space-efficient and budget-friendly. They are ideal for smaller bathrooms where space is limited, making them a practical option for compact areas.

Height and Comfort

  • Standard Height Toilets: Standard-height toilets are the most common and are comfortable for many users. They are suitable for most households and provide a familiar and easy-to-use design.
  • Comfort Height Toilets: These toilets are taller than standard ones, often referred to as “chair height” toilets. They are designed to make sitting down and standing up more accessible, particularly for individuals with mobility concerns.

Seat Options

  • Soft-Close Seats: Soft-close toilet seats prevent loud slamming and gently lower the seat and lid, reducing noise and preventing wear and tear. They add a touch of convenience to your bathroom.
  • Heated Seats: Heated toilet seats offer a touch of luxury, especially during colder months. They provide a cozy and comfortable experience, ensuring your comfort even in chilly weather.

Flushing Mechanisms

  • Gravity-fed Flushing: These toilets use the force of gravity to remove waste and are known for their quiet operation. They are a reliable and low-maintenance choice, making them a practical option for many households.
  • Pressure-assisted Flushing: Pressure-assisted toilets use air pressure to force water into the bowl, resulting in a powerful flush. While they are efficient in waste removal, they can be noisier than gravity-fed models.

Understanding these key features will empower you to choose a toilet that aligns with your specific preferences and requirements. Whether you prioritize water efficiency, comfort, or convenience, these features offer a range of options to cater to your needs.

choose the right toilet

Evaluating Bathroom Space

Selecting the right toilet for your home isn’t just about style and functionality; it’s also about ensuring that it fits comfortably within your bathroom space. In this section, we’ll guide you through the process of evaluating your bathroom’s dimensions and layout to make sure your chosen toilet is a perfect fit.

How to Measure Your Bathroom

Before you embark on selecting a toilet, it’s crucial to take accurate measurements of your bathroom space. Follow these simple steps to ensure a precise evaluation:

  • Measure the Rough-In: The rough-in is the distance from the wall behind the toilet to the center of the drainpipe. Most toilets have a standard rough-in of 12 inches, but some may require 10 or 14 inches. Measure this distance carefully to match it with the toilet’s rough-in specification.
  • Check Clearances: Ensure there is sufficient space around the toilet for comfortable use. Measure the distance from the toilet to nearby walls, vanities, or other fixtures. Aim for a minimum clearance of 15 inches on each side of the toilet and at least 24 inches in front of it.
  • Consider Door Swing: If your bathroom door swings open near the toilet area, take that into account when measuring. Make sure there’s enough room for the door to open and close without obstructing the toilet.

Finding the Right Size Toilet

Once you have accurate measurements, you can determine the appropriate size of the toilet that fits your bathroom layout comfortably. Keep in mind that the size of the toilet bowl, tank, and seat can vary, so choose a toilet that not only fits within the available space but also allows for easy movement and access.

The Impact of Bathroom Layout

Consider how your toilet’s placement will impact the overall layout and flow of your bathroom. Will it provide ample space for other essential fixtures like a bathtub or shower? Additionally, think about how the placement of your toilet will affect privacy and convenience within your bathroom.

By evaluating your bathroom space meticulously, you’ll be able to select a toilet that not only complements your bathroom’s design but also ensures optimal functionality and comfort. This step is crucial in making your bathroom a comfortable and efficient space for your daily routine.

Efficiency and Water Conservation

In today’s environmentally conscious world, water conservation is a key consideration when choosing a toilet. The level of water efficiency can not only reduce your environmental footprint but also have a significant impact on your water bills. In this section, we’ll explore various aspects of toilet efficiency and how to choose a toilet that aligns with your water-saving goals.

The Significance of Water Efficiency

Water efficiency is an essential factor to consider when selecting a toilet. The average American household uses a significant amount of water each day, with a substantial portion going toward flushing toilets. Choosing a water-efficient toilet can significantly reduce your water consumption, helping conserve this precious resource and lower your utility costs.

Understanding Flush Ratings (GPF)

To assess a toilet’s water efficiency, you’ll often encounter the term “GPF,” which stands for “Gallons Per Flush.” It represents the volume of water used by the toilet with each flush. Here’s what you need to know about GPF ratings:

  • Low GPF: Toilets with lower GPF ratings use less water per flush, making them more water-efficient. Common low GPF options include 1.28 GPF and even ultra-low flush toilets with 1.0 GPF.
  • Standard GPF: Traditional toilets typically use around 1.6 GPF. While not as water-efficient as lower GPF models, these can still provide efficient flushing.
  • High GPF: Some older toilets use significantly more water, around 3.5 GPF or more. Replacing these with more water-efficient options can lead to substantial water savings.

Eco-Friendly Options for Water Conservation

Toilets designed with eco-friendliness in mind offer various features to promote water conservation:

  • Pressure-Assisted Toilets: These toilets use air pressure to create a powerful flush, allowing for effective waste removal while using less water.
  • Dual Flush Toilets: Dual flush toilets provide the option for a partial flush (for liquid waste) or a full flush (for solid waste), helping conserve water based on your needs.
  • EPA WaterSense Label: Look for the EPA WaterSense label when choosing a toilet. Toilets with this label meet strict water efficiency and performance criteria, ensuring you’re making an environmentally responsible choice.

By opting for a water-efficient toilet, you not only contribute to water conservation efforts but also enjoy reduced water bills over time. Consider your environmental impact and budget when selecting a toilet that aligns with your water-saving goals.

Budget Considerations

As you embark on the journey of choosing the right toilet for your home, it’s essential to establish a clear budget. Your budget will play a significant role in determining the range of options available to you and ensure that you make a choice that aligns with your financial goals. In this section, we’ll explore the importance of setting a budget, finding the right balance between cost and quality, and cost-effective options for various needs.

Setting a Budget for Your Toilet

Before you start browsing for toilets, take the time to establish a budget that reflects your financial capacity and goals. Keep in mind that the cost of toilets can vary significantly, from budget-friendly options to high-end luxury models. Setting a budget helps you narrow down your choices and prevents you from overspending.

Finding the Balance Between Cost and Quality

While it’s important to stick to your budget, it’s equally crucial to find a toilet that offers a balance between cost and quality. Cheaper toilets might save you money initially, but they can cost more in the long run if they lack durability or water efficiency. On the other hand, luxurious models can provide advanced features, but they may not be necessary for every household.

Consider the following factors when balancing cost and quality:

  • Durability: Investing in a toilet that’s built to last can save you money on repairs and replacements in the future.
  • Water Efficiency: Opt for a toilet that offers water-saving features, even within your budget. The long-term water savings can offset the initial cost.
  • Brand Reputation: Research toilet brands known for their quality and reliability. These brands often offer a range of options to suit different budgets.

Cost-Effective Options for Various Needs

If you’re on a tight budget, there are cost-effective toilet options available that still provide quality and efficiency. Consider these options:

  • Economical Two-Piece Toilets: Two-piece toilets are often budget-friendly and can be a practical choice for many households.
  • Low-Flow Toilets: Low-flow toilets offer water efficiency without a high price tag. Look for models that meet EPA WaterSense standards.
  • Budget-Friendly Brands: Some reputable brands offer budget-friendly models without compromising on quality. Explore their product lines for affordable options.

By setting a budget and striking a balance between cost and quality, you can choose a toilet that meets your needs without straining your finances. This approach ensures that you make a smart investment in a crucial household fixture.

choose the right toilet

Installation and Maintenance

Selecting the right toilet for your home is only one part of the process. Equally important is the proper installation and regular maintenance of your chosen fixture to ensure long-lasting performance and avoid future issues. In this section, we’ll delve into considerations for installing and maintaining your toilet, with a special focus on how Service by Scott can assist you in this crucial aspect.

DIY vs. Professional Installation

Before you embark on the installation process, you’ll need to decide whether you want to tackle it yourself or seek professional assistance. DIY installation can be a cost-effective option if you have the necessary skills and experience. However, for those who are not confident in their plumbing abilities, professional installation is highly recommended. It ensures that your toilet is installed correctly, minimizing the risk of leaks and other problems.

If you opt for professional installation, Service by Scott is your reliable partner. With over 30 years of experience serving Tyler County and its neighbors, our experts have the knowledge and expertise to install your toilet efficiently and professionally. We ensure that your new toilet is seamlessly integrated into your plumbing system.

Tips for a Successful Installation

Whether you decide to install the toilet yourself or have professionals handle it, here are some essential tips for a successful installation:

  • Proper Alignment: Ensure that the toilet is correctly aligned with the floor flange for a watertight seal. Use a wax ring or a wax-free gasket to prevent leaks.
  • Secure Bolts: Tighten the closet bolts securely, but be careful not to overtighten, which can crack the toilet base.
  • Seal the Base: Apply a bead of caulk around the base of the toilet to prevent water and debris from seeping underneath.
  • Water Supply Connection: Connect the water supply line to the fill valve and check for any leaks after turning on the water.

Regular Maintenance for Longevity

To keep your toilet in optimal condition, regular maintenance is essential. This includes checking for and addressing issues such as:

  • Leaky Seals: Inspect and replace wax rings or gaskets if you notice water around the base of the toilet.
  • Running Toilet: If your toilet continues to run after flushing, it may require adjustments to the fill valve or flapper.
  • Clogs and Blockages: Use a plunger or a toilet auger to clear clogs, and avoid flushing non-flushable items down the toilet.
  • Water Efficiency: Regularly check for water-saving features and ensure they are functioning correctly.

For professional maintenance, Service by Scott is your trusted partner. Our team can perform routine maintenance checks on your toilet and address any issues promptly. We are available for both scheduled maintenance and emergency repairs, ensuring that your toilet remains in perfect working order.

By considering installation and maintenance, you can ensure that your chosen toilet operates efficiently and trouble-free for years to come, and Service by Scott is here to assist you every step of the way.

choose the right toilet

Personal Preferences and Aesthetics

Beyond the technical considerations of selecting a toilet, it’s important to remember that personal preferences and aesthetics play a significant role in making your bathroom a space that you truly enjoy. In this section, we’ll explore how to align your individual style and design choices with your toilet selection, ensuring that your bathroom is both functional and visually pleasing.

Choosing a Toilet Style

The style of your toilet can significantly impact the overall aesthetics of your bathroom. Consider the following options to match your personal preferences:

  • Classic: Classic toilets feature timeless designs with clean lines and neutral colors, making them versatile and suitable for a wide range of bathroom styles.
  • Contemporary: For a modern and sleek look, contemporary toilets often come in bold shapes and colors. They can add a touch of elegance to your bathroom.
  • Vintage: Vintage or retro toilets evoke a sense of nostalgia and can be a charming addition to bathrooms with a classic theme.

Customization Options

Toilets today offer a range of customization options to cater to your unique preferences:

  • Color: While white remains the most popular color for toilets, you can choose from a variety of colors to match your bathroom decor.
  • Design: Consider toilets with unique design elements, such as decorative tank lids or artistic bowl shapes, to add a personal touch.
  • Seat Material: Toilet seats are available in various materials, including wood, plastic, and soft-closing options. Choose a material that complements your preferences.

Matching with Other Bathroom Fixtures

To create a cohesive and harmonious bathroom design, ensure that your chosen toilet complements other fixtures and elements in the space. Coordinate the color, style, and design of your toilet with your sink, bathtub, and shower to achieve a unified look.

By considering personal preferences and aesthetics, you’ll create a bathroom that not only serves your practical needs but also reflects your unique taste and style, ensuring that your haven is a space you’re proud of.


In conclusion, selecting the right toilet for your home is a decision that goes beyond functionality and design; it’s about aligning your personal preferences and practical needs. Understanding the various toilet types, key features, water efficiency, budget considerations, bathroom space, and aesthetics empowers you to make an informed choice.

As you embark on this journey, remember that your bathroom should not only serve as a place of convenience but also reflect your unique style and values. Whether you prioritize water conservation, budget-conscious choices, or luxurious designs, the perfect toilet is out there to meet your expectations.

We understand that this process can be both exciting and challenging, and that’s where Service by Scott is here to assist. With over 30 years of experience serving Woodville, Texas, and its neighboring areas, our team is dedicated to helping you find the ideal toilet for your home. We provide professional installation, maintenance, and plumbing expertise, ensuring that your chosen toilet functions flawlessly for years to come.

So, when you’re ready to take the next step in your journey to find the perfect toilet, contact Service by Scott. We are your trusted partner in making your bathroom not only efficient but also a reflection of your unique style. Let us help you turn your bathroom dreams into reality. Don’t hesitate to get in touch with us for all your plumbing needs.


What’s the difference between a two-piece and a one-piece toilet?

A two-piece toilet consists of a separate tank and bowl, making it easier to maintain and more budget-friendly. In contrast, a one-piece toilet has a seamless design with no crevices between the tank and bowl, offering a sleek look and easier cleaning.

How do I know if a toilet is water-efficient?

Check the Gallons Per Flush (GPF) rating. Lower GPF means greater water efficiency. Look for toilets with a dual flush system, low-flow technology, or the EPA WaterSense label, as they are designed to save water without compromising performance.

What’s the standard toilet height, and how does it differ from comfort height?

The standard toilet height is around 15 inches, while a comfort height toilet is typically 17 to 19 inches high. Comfort height toilets, also known as “chair height,” are more comfortable for individuals with mobility issues.

What’s the best material for a toilet seat?

Toilet seats are commonly made of plastic, wood, or soft-closing materials. Plastic seats are durable and easy to clean, while wood seats offer a classic look. Soft-closing seats prevent slamming and add a touch of luxury.

How can I coordinate my toilet with the rest of my bathroom fixtures?

To create a harmonious bathroom design, consider matching the color, style, and design of your toilet with your sink, bathtub, and shower. This ensures a unified look that complements your bathroom’s overall aesthetics.